8.4/10 Brilliant, brave, but burdened by its own weight—watch it not for answers, but for the abyss staring back.

One IMDB user writes, “This is not Mirzapur. This is dread in slow motion.” The praise is reserved for the world-building—the misty forests, the silent rifles, the long takes where nothing happens, yet everything is threatened. Jaideep Ahlawat’s Hathi Ram Chaudhary returns not as a triumphant hero but as a broken, gasping animal, and reviewers argue that his performance alone warrants a rating above 9. For them, Season 2 is a masterpiece of sustained unease. Yet, scroll past the 10-star adoration, and you find a string of 5s and 6s—unusual for a cult hit. The criticism is pointed. A recurring IMDB complaint is pacing . Where Season 1 exploded with caste violence and raw dialogue, Season 2 is accused of being “arthouse slow.” One reviewer laments, “Four episodes of walking in jungles, then 20 minutes of payoff.”

When Paatal Lok first premiered in 2020, it didn’t just arrive—it detonated. Amazon Prime’s gritty noir redefined Indian streaming, earning a loyal following and a sturdy IMDB rating of 8.1/10 . Four years later, Season 2 returns, and its IMDB page has become a battleground of expectation, fatigue, and reluctant admiration. With a current score hovering around 8.4–8.6 (as of early 2026), the verdict is clear: Paatal Lok has not fallen, but it has deepened—and that very depth is dividing its audience. The Rise: What the High Rating Celebrates The overwhelming majority of 8+ star reviews on IMDB praise one thing above all: atmosphere over action . Season 2 shifts its gaze from the alleys of Delhi to the icy, blood-soaked badlands of Nagaland. Reviewers consistently highlight the show’s audacity to abandon familiar urban crime tropes for a geopolitical thriller about insurgency, state violence, and tribal identity.