Marco, eager to please, grabbed a can of leftover trim paint. “Of course you can paint marble,” he said. “It’s just stone.”

Marble windowsills are like hardwood floors. You can paint them, but you’ll regret losing the original beauty and durability. Restore, don’t paint.

That afternoon, he cleaned the sill, taped the edges, and rolled on a coat of glossy white latex. It looked fantastic—for about four hours. Then the problems began.

Hours of Operation